Blinded design comparison

design-taste-3directions-camouflage-ko-r1-20260730

  1. Judge design first. Score every dimension from 1 to 5.
  2. Do not try to infer which route is the current production page.
  3. Name a single overall winner, and say in one sentence what would have to change for a different route to win.
  4. Flag any route that states a fact the venue evidence does not support.

Score each route on: first_impression_and_originality, typographic_craft, layout_and_whitespace, photographic_art_direction, brand_memorability, overall_luxury, mobile_intent_retention, reduced_ai_cliche

Route 1

Desktop 1440
Route 1 desktop
Mobile 390
Route 1 mobile
Mobile 360
Route 1 mobile_360
static signal (source-text heuristic)value
max font-size (vw)8.5
non-zero border-radius decls1
box-shadow decls3
text-align:center decls2
gradient decls1
distinct aspect-ratio values3
figcaption / blockquote0 / 0
sections6
reduced-motion / focus-visible / text-size-adjustTrue / True / True

Route 2

Desktop 1440
Route 2 desktop
Mobile 390
Route 2 mobile
Mobile 360
Route 2 mobile_360
static signal (source-text heuristic)value
max font-size (vw)8.0
non-zero border-radius decls15
box-shadow decls4
text-align:center decls4
gradient decls1
distinct aspect-ratio values1
figcaption / blockquote0 / 0
sections6
reduced-motion / focus-visible / text-size-adjustTrue / True / True

Route 3

Desktop 1440
Route 3 desktop
Mobile 390
Route 3 mobile
Mobile 360
Route 3 mobile_360
static signal (source-text heuristic)value
max font-size (vw)7.5
non-zero border-radius decls19
box-shadow decls5
text-align:center decls0
gradient decls0
distinct aspect-ratio values3
figcaption / blockquote0 / 1
sections7
reduced-motion / focus-visible / text-size-adjustTrue / True / True

Route 4

Desktop 1440
Route 4 desktop
Mobile 390
Route 4 mobile
Mobile 360
Route 4 mobile_360
static signal (source-text heuristic)value
max font-size (vw)9.0
non-zero border-radius decls16
box-shadow decls1
text-align:center decls0
gradient decls1
distinct aspect-ratio values3
figcaption / blockquote0 / 0
sections6
reduced-motion / focus-visible / text-size-adjustTrue / True / True